The Many Faces of Democracy

#162, March 2, 2005

 

What comes to mind when you hear the word “democracy”? Cleisthenes, the founder of Greek democracy, clad in his white linen chlamys as he presides over the downfall of the tyrant oligarchs? George Bush proclaiming his “victory” in 2000? American voters in blue states and red states? Iraqi voters with their blue-died fingers and red-stained streets?

 

When I hear democracy, I think of the line of citizens waiting to talk at a public hearing in the main room of Petaluma’s Cavanagh center. In this Norman Rockwellesque scene, fellow citizens speak their minds and, one by one, change the minds of City officials. The way it should be.

 

How much do we truly value democratic freedom? Do we take it for granted? Is it worth the 20,000 lives and 200 billion dollars spent to knock down and rebuild Iraq in America’s image? (BTW, $400 million of the $200 billion is coming from Sonoma County – see nationalpriorities.org.  When will this nation put some serious money into finding a better way to liberate people than by killing people? Is freedom through violence sustainable in a nuclear-armed world?)

 

It’s noble of our President to preach freedom to Russian President Putin, but Putin’s shrewd enough to know Bush’s bottom line: freedom for international capital. Am I being over-the-top cynical to suggest that the Bushmen care less about Russian press freedom than the liberty of the Russian oligarchs incarcerated by Putin, those billionaire capitalists who made their killing during the fire sale liquidation of Soviet state assets? If so, please explain why the Bushies supported the unsuccessful 2002 coup against democratically elected Venezuelan President Hugo Chavez, and supported a 2004 recall of Chavez that failed by a 58-42 margin? Was it because Chavez fought for expansion of government support for the poor, and against privatization of the country’s huge oil reserves?

 

And freedom of the press? Karl Rove’s far too clever to try a Putin-style shut down of American media. Much easier, it is, to enable media consolidation in the hands of conservative capitalists (Fox’s Rupert Murdoch), to put conservative pundits on the White House payroll (Armstrong Williams), to let Republican Party shills (Jeff Gannon aka James Guckert) pose as journalists and lob softballs to Bush at White House briefings. The strategy: democracy dies so slowly that the majority fails even to notice. So, fellow citizens, when you hear about the “ownership society” and “Operation Iraqi Freedom”, ask: who will be free to own the oil? Who will be free to own the media? And who will own the voting machines?

 

We need Operation American Freedom. North Bay’s very own Senator Boxer just co-introduced (with Senator Clinton) the “Count Every Vote Act of 2005”. This measure covers a long list of voting reforms, including the requirement of voter-verified paper ballot for all electronic voting machines. And I say: if democracy truly is precious to us, why on earth would we put the very foundation of democracy – the ballot – under the control of the private companies who manufacture electronic voting machines? This should be a state run enterprise, using open-source (not proprietary) computer code. Says author Thom Hartmann, “Our vote is too important to be outsourced to private corporations.”

 

While we’re at it, let’s continue Operation Petaluma Freedom. Voters overwhelmingly approved the Campaign Finance Reform ordinance last November, a significant step in reducing the corrupting influences on the City Council. But the Council’s actions on the garbage hauling contract suggest that more should be done. Petaluma Tomorrow is circulating advisory petitions urging the Council to adopt guidelines for ethical conduct in awarding franchise agreements and other major contracts. The guidelines would: 1) prohibit private meetings with bidders during bidding and negotiation; 2) provide for termination of contracts if the contractee is convicted of certain crimes, such as bribery, fraud, and price fixing; and 3) prevent the contractee from making campaign contributions to Council Members. Get a petition at www.petaluma-tomorrow.org.

 

I heard it so often in my youth: “with freedom comes responsibility.” Today, if we don’t take personal responsibility for engaging in democracy to protect our freedom, our freedom will soon be gone.